Why "just checking in" gets archived
A social media lead is someone who found you through Instagram, TikTok or YouTube, gave you an email on a lead page or quiz, and is now quietly deciding whether you are their agent. Nobody tells you they are deciding. They just watch.
That is why social leads take 6 to 12 months to convert, while paid portal leads take 1 to 3. A portal lead raised their hand because they wanted a showing this week. A social lead raised their hand because your content made sense. Different clock entirely.
So your follow-up has to survive a long stretch where the lead has nothing to say back. "Just checking in" fails that test because it asks them to do the work. It brings no information, no number, no listing. It is an email about you needing a reply.
The emails that survive the 6 to 12 month window all do the same three things: they bring one new piece of value, they ask one small question, and they make silence okay. Every prompt below is built around that.
One thing before any of this works
The lead has to exist. If your profile link sends people to a brokerage site from 2012 or a generic link tree, there is no email to write to. Capture the email first (a lead page, a quiz, a "what's my home worth" form on your link-in-bio), then the prompts below have somewhere to go. Months of great content with no email list is the most common hole in an agent's funnel.
The one prompt that writes any follow-up email
You do not need twenty prompts. You need one prompt with four blanks. Fill the blanks and the model does the rest.
Using my voice guide, write an email. Scenario: {{one of the twenty scenarios below}}. Recipient: {{who they are, our relationship, what they already know}}. Facts: {{the specifics: addresses, numbers, dates}}. Goal: {{the one thing I want them to do or feel}}. Format: subject line + 90 to 140 words + one clear next step. Tone: {{warm / crisp / reassuring}}. No "I hope this finds you well." No "just checking in."
What goes in the braces
- Scenario tells the model which of the twenty emails this is, so it stops guessing at structure.
- Recipient matters more than agents think. "First-time buyer, met at the Elm Street open house, nervous about rates" produces a completely different email than "past client, closed two years ago."
- Facts are where the value lives. Two addresses and one price beat three paragraphs of warmth.
- Goal is a single sentence. "Book a 15-minute call" or "feel reassured that a low appraisal is survivable." One goal per email, always.
The "voice guide" is a short description of how you write (sentence length, warmth, what you never say) that you paste at the top of the chat or save into your assistant's memory. In 2026 the major assistants remember it between sessions, so you write it once. Agentree's Teach AI Your Voice does the same thing from one caption, one listing description and one client email, with no prompt box, if you would rather skip the setup.
Twenty scenarios you can stop writing from scratch
Nearly every email a working agent sends falls into one of these. Pick the number, drop it into the scenario blank, and move on with your day.
- Cold outreach to an expired listing
- Cold outreach to a FSBO
- New online lead, first touch
- Open-house visitor follow-up
- Lead went quiet, value re-engage
- Booking a 15-minute plan call
- Buyer welcome packet intro
- Seller welcome and prep plan
- Price-reduction conversation
- Delivering difficult news
- Weekly update to an active seller
- Weekly update to an active buyer
- Offer submitted, what happens next
- Offer rejected, next steps
- Inspection results and options
- Low appraisal explanation
- Closing-week checklist
- Post-closing thank-you and review ask
- House-iversary check-in
- Monthly newsletter
Notice how many of these are about the long middle: scenarios 5, 6, 19 and 20 exist purely to stay in the inbox during the months when a social lead is still deciding. Those four emails are the ones most agents never send, and they are the ones that decide who gets the call a year later.
Two drafted examples
Here is scenario 5, the quiet lead, run through the prompt with a warm tone. Subject line: Two homes near {{street}} you'd want to see.
Hi {{name}}, no pressure at all. Two homes came up this week that fit what you described: {{one line each}}. Want the links? Either way, I'll stop here unless you say otherwise.
Under fifty words. One new thing of value (two specific homes). One question. Silence is explicitly okay. That last sentence is what makes a quiet lead feel safe replying three months later.
And scenario 18, the post-closing thank-you. Subject line: Congratulations, and one small favor.
Hi {{name}}, the keys are yours. One small favor: a quick Google review helps the next family find me the way you did. If you are up for it, three things that make a review useful: what you were worried about, what we did about it, and how it ended. Thank you for trusting me with this one. Enjoy every Saturday morning in that kitchen.
The review ask works because it tells them exactly what to write. "Leave a review" gets ignored. "Mention these three things" gets a paragraph.
Replies, nudges and subject lines
Two more prompts cover the emails that are not fresh drafts: answering what landed in your inbox, and nudging the one that got no answer.
Reply to any email
Here is an email I received: {{paste}}. Reply in my voice. Address every question they asked, in order. Keep the same level of formality. If they raised a concern, acknowledge it in one sentence before answering. End with one next step and a time.
"In order" is the important instruction. Clients notice when you answered questions two and three and skipped question one, and that is usually the one they cared about.
Follow up on an unanswered email
Here is the email I sent {{days}} ago with no reply: {{paste}}. Write a short follow-up in my voice. Do not repeat the original; add one new thing of value ({{a listing, a number, a date}}). Assume they are busy, not uninterested. Under 70 words, one question, one time option. No "just checking in."
"Assume they are busy, not uninterested" changes the whole draft. A model told the lead is uninterested writes a guilt trip. A model told the lead is busy writes something you can actually send.
Subject line rules
The subject line decides whether the 120 words you just edited get read at all. The rules are short:
- Specific beats clever. "Two homes near Elm St you'd want to see" wins over "Exciting news!" every time.
- Under 45 characters. Phones cut the rest.
- Use their street, their name or their number. Anything that proves this email could only be for them.
- Never "Checking in" or "Following up." Those two words are a filter for the delete key.
- Ask for three and pick one. Add "Give me three subject lines: plain, curious, urgent but honest" to any prompt and choose the one that sounds like you.
The tone dial and the human in the loop
One word in the tone blank is enough to reshape the whole email. Keep this dial in your head:
- Reassuring for nervous buyers (scenarios 13 through 16 especially).
- Crisp for attorneys and lenders.
- Warm for past clients and house-iversaries.
- Direct for price talks. Nobody wants a price reduction wrapped in cotton.
Automate the "got it," keep the human line
The goal is not to automate your relationships. The goal is to automate the parts that were never personal to begin with so you have time for the parts that are.
- Automate the instant "got it, I'll be in touch today" reply to a new lead. Keep the five-minute personal follow-up human.
- Automate the review-request reminder a week after closing. Keep the closing-day thank-you human.
- Automate the monthly newsletter draft. Keep the one line at the top that references something only you would know about that neighborhood.
Your job is the two-minute edit and the one human line. The model drafts, you read it on your phone between showings, you add the sentence about the dog they mentioned or the coffee shop that just opened on their street, and you hit send. That one line is what the lead remembers in month nine when they finally reply.